What if a subcontractor caused a construction defect?

You finished a home renovation a few months ago. Now the homeowner calls about rainwater leaking around the new windows. They want your company to pay for repairs, even though you hired another crew to install them. You still have jobs to finish and workers to pay. An unexpected repair bill would put more pressure on your budget.

Hiring another crew does not automatically free your company from responsibility for the work. As the main contractor, you may still face a claim from the homeowner. If the installer caused the leak, however, your agreement with that crew might help you recover some of the repair costs.

Check what the crew agreed to do

A subcontractor is a separate business you hire for part of a job. Your written agreement generally lists the tasks that business will handle. For instance, the installer might have agreed to seal the window frames against rain.

That agreement tells you what the installer promised, but it does not prove who caused the leak. Photos from the job and inspection notes could help show whether the seal failed. They also help you see whether water reached the walls.

Review who may cover the bill

Some subcontracts contain an indemnity clause. This means one business agrees to cover certain losses or legal costs for another. If the installer caused the leak, the clause may support a request for payment toward repairs.

California law limits these clauses. For some projects, it blocks terms that make the installer pay for damage from your own faulty work. It also restricts terms that cover problems outside the installer’s duties. The type of project and the date you signed the contract affect which limits apply.

Respond with the job records

You may want to save the owner’s complaint and ask the installer to explain its work. Reading both accounts with the agreement could help you assess the claim before you discuss repair costs. Those records also give you facts to respond to a lawsuit if the owner takes the dispute to court.